Fighting the Benoni: The Remarkable Nh5 Idea

Benoni (Indo-Benoni) is one of the few aggressive options black has against the move 1.d4. It is an audacious defense that seeks counterplay and dynamism from the very start of the game. Nowadays it has disappeared almost completely from the top level.

Apparently, the majority of the high-rank players think it’s too risky and positionally unsound. Or maybe it just went out of fashion. However, it did have its golden age. In the times of Fischer and Tal, the Indo-Benoni became a dangerous weapon in the hand of those players who didn’t want to settle for “only equality” as black against 1.d4. Besides, the two mentioned World Champions there were many gladiators in the Benoni.

Part 1

Just to mention a few, Mihai Suba (a great expert), Lev Psakhis, Mihai Marin. There are many plans and typical ideas, but for this article, we want to focus on one remarkable move in the Benoni structure and that move is Nh5. This move shocked the world when Bobby Fischer played it against Spassky.

See the diagram below:

A strange-looking move that allows white to capture the knight, ruining black’s kingside pawns and leaving his structure somewhat weakened. However, things are not so simple. In return for his damaged pawns black gets some activity on the kingside. The H pawn can be thrown forward in order to attack the white king.

Black also has the long diagonal opened for his g7 bishop and the pawn break f7-f5 is definitely in the cards.

Ready to start systematic training that actually works?

Click here to start your training using the day-by-day program.

We have to say that this move can hardly surprise anyone these days, but it is not played too often either. Perhaps black fears he will not get as much activity in return for his weaknesses?

Was it an original idea of Bobby Fischer?

According to our database, this idea had already been played a few times in similar positions before Fischer played it against Spassky. However, it was a novelty in the exact position of that game.

In which situations should black seriously consider playing Nh5?

Benoni – Part 2

This is a tough question to answer as we must always consider concrete details. However, there are a few patterns that can serve us as a guide. Assuming that white will take on h5 after gxh5 black should consider the following points:

• His pieces become potentially active;

• The idea of h5-h4 and in some cases h4-h3 can create problems for white;

• The central rupture with f7-f5 becomes easier to achieve;

• White is not able to attack the f5 square with a knight;

• White is not able to use the open g file to attack the black king.

We believe that when making such a positionally risky move like Nh5, everything has to be justified with concrete moves, but the points mentioned above are good considerations to remember.

The structure in action

Let’s have a look now at a few games in which black chooses to play this way and how the battle developed afterward.

Naturally, our first example is the famous Fischer game. Fischer demonstrated the power of black’s piece activity and the dynamism that black has despite the shattered kingside pawns. A game worth seeing as many times as you wish.

Our second example is a game played short after Fischer’s game between the GM Gligoric and GM Kavalek. Gligoric shows a very nice plan for white to neutralize black’s initiative.

Finally, our last example is a crushing victory of the GM Maxim Dlugy as white against the GM Thomas Wedberg. Dlugy follows Gligoric’s path which is considered the best way to deal with Nh5.

Looking for more on Benoni Defense? Look at this article: Complete Guide.

Conclusion

In a conclusion, we believe Nh5 is very risky for black; nevertheless, complicated games can always go either way. The plan shown by Gligoric with Nd1-Ra3 seems, if not a refutation, at least a very uncomfortable plan for black. Thanks for reading!

If you want to improve your chess level, you need to have a clear study plan. If you aim for a dramatic improvement at chess you need to work on all of the elements of the game in a systematic way:

• tactics
• positional play
• attacking skills
• endgame technique
• classical games analysis
• psychological preparation
• and much more

That seems to be like a lot of things, and that is. But no worries, we have made it easy for you. Our comprehensive training course covers it all and much more. Sign up for 21 Day Training right now!

Image Credits: Flickr creative commons license by Barney Moss.